Sony Loses Patent Battle

Found on Techdirt on Sunday, 27 March 2005
Browse Legal-Issues

If you're familiar with the word "haptics," you're familiar with the company Immersion. They're the company that seems to own every possible patent having to do with the haptics space, and any kind of tactile response or force feedback device usually involves patents that were first licensed from the company. So, in some ways, it's pretty impressive that Sony has gotten as far as it has apparently without licensing patents from the company. A court has found, however, that Sony's force feedback controllers for the PlayStation and PlayStation 2 violate Immersion's patents and not only have they ordered the company to pay $90 million in damages, but also told Sony it can no longer sell either console in the US. Sony, of course, will appeal the ruling, which will allow them to keep selling the consoles in the meantime. Of course, this is the same Sony that keeps insisting on the importance of stricter intellectual property enforcement to teach violators a lesson. Funny what comes back to bite you...

Laws aren't as funny when they work against you; which is especially entertaining when you have been pushing that law before. Of course you can always ignore it and hope nobody will notice, but when it comes to patents and IP, chances are quite low. Ignoring patents and copyrights seems to be pretty common amongst companies: SCO uses files without asking or giving credit too.