Music biz: piracy our "climate change," governments must act!

Found on Ars Technica on Thursday, 21 January 2010
Browse Legal-Issues

According to this view of the world, the music business has now tried its hand at being "innovative" and "customer focused."

IFPI admits that only 15 percent of European Internet users even engage in piracy at all, and it further admits that many of these users purchase music, but it still claims that piracy is the "fundamental problem."

As for what's selling, these are the major labels, so the top 10 singles are pretty execrable stuff unless you like Lady Gaga, Britney Spears, or songs with titles like "Kiss Me Thru the Phone" and "Boom Boom Pow."

Over the years, the industry has turned music into something totally uninteresting for me. It's not even worth sharing it because, honestly, all that mainstream music is worthless. Free (as in beer) music is more interesting and, not to forget, less dangerous for the everyday downloader. So, thanks to the big labels for their log-time efforts to drive users away from their content and for bringing attention to those artists who don't mind filesharing because they realized it only helps them.

China Tells Google to Follow the Law

Found on eWEEK on Wednesday, 13 January 2010
Browse Legal-Issues

The Chinese government had a relatively straightforward response Jan. 14 to Google's threat to stop censoring searches on its Chinese language site, Google.cn: Follow the law.

"This incident should be equally troubling to the Chinese government. The administration encourages the government of China to work with Google and other U.S. companies to ensure a climate for secure commercial operations in the Chinese market."

All that is not much of a problem. China's law which enforces censorship is nothing one would like to follow. Of course, China doesn't want that. So, to make everybody happy, pull out of China. If you are not doing any business there, you don't need to follow their laws. And if China is not happy with what you are doing online, they can just block you.

French 3 Strikes Group Unveils Copyright Infringing Logo

Found on TorrentFreak on Tuesday, 12 January 2010
Browse Legal-Issues

Last week the group unveiled the logo which is set to represent this bastion of copyright righteousness, but embarrassingly it was designed with unlicensed fonts.

"The problem is, this font was an 'exclusive corporate typeface'. It couldn't be used for other purposes than France Telecom/Orange products," he told us.

Yesterday there was panic, as Hadopi tried to repair the damage by sourcing new matching fonts they could license legally.

Sarkozy's government strikes again. Their list of copyright violations is growing fast: using music without permission (twice even), counterfeiting 400 DVDs and now this.

Nigerian accused of attacking US passenger jet

Found on BBC News on Friday, 25 December 2009
Browse Legal-Issues

A Nigerian man has been charged with attempting to destroy a plane after he allegedly tried to detonate a bomb on a passenger jet arriving in the US.

Mr Abdulmutallab reportedly told investigators he had links to al-Qaeda and had received the explosives in Yemen.

A preliminary investigation found that security procedures were followed correctly, and the man had a valid US visa.

A black person, trained by Al-Qaeda in Yemen, who is on a list of people having significant terrorist connections got a valid visa and went through all security checks even though his parents warned officials before. This leaves the US security officials with the reddest face ever; but at the same time, they will demand more rights for privacy violations to increase the monitoring of everybody, not realizing that there will always be someone who can get through.

Woman arrested for trying to record 'Twilight' on digital camera

Found on Sun-Times on Friday, 04 December 2009
Browse Legal-Issues

The 22-year-old Chicago woman faces up to three years in prison after being charged with a rarely invoked felony designed to prevent movie patrons from recording hot new movies and selling bootleg copies.

She was actually taping parts of her sister's surprise birthday party celebrated at the Muvico Theater in Rosemont.

Tumpach was arrested after theater managers insisted on pressing charges, he said. She was charged with criminal use of a motion picture exhibition.

There's footage of she and her relatives singing to her sister, she said. "We sang 'Happy Birthday' to her in the theater," Tumpach said.

Yes, two nights in jail and maybe up to three more years for having a birthday party at a theater. And managers wonder why people don't go to the theaters anymore. Talk about being out of proportion. I guess she's still lucky because so far, the music industry hasn't joined the lawsuit because they performed "Happy Birthday" in public. In case anybody wonders where that happened: Muvico Theaters, 9701 Bryn Mawr Avenue, Rosemont, IL 60018-5210.

Cartoon smut law to make life sucky for Olympic organisers

Found on The Register on Saturday, 28 November 2009
Browse Legal-Issues

The horror facing the unpopular Olympics logo is that this is a strict liability offence.

It was the logo's perceived suggestiveness - with many sniggering that it appeared to show Lisa Simpson performing an act of fellatio - that excited internet controversy.

Google variants on "Olympic logo" plus "Lisa Simpson", "fellatio", "blow job", etc and you will quickly turn up several thousand sites and articles which link those topics.

This "similarity" is so far-fetched that it made me laugh. If legislators really have nothing better to do than outlawing images which aren't even pornographic when you're on the worst drugs you can get, then they should look for a new job. I'm sure the human (ie alive) victims of abuse will feel way safer now that drawn porn is getting investigated with all available police forces.

Roman Polanski awaits move from prison to house arrest

Found on BBC News on Friday, 27 November 2009
Browse Legal-Issues

Film director Roman Polanski will not be released from prison until Monday at the earliest, the Swiss justice ministry has confirmed.

Polanski was accused of raping a 13-year-old girl after plying her with champagne and a sedative during a modelling shoot in 1977.

Polanski fled the US in February 1978 on the day he was to be sentenced, and has lived in France since then.

He dug his own hole; if he wouldn't have fled back then, he wouldn't be in trouble now. So, off to jail he goes.

In AU, Film Studios Issue Ultimatum To ISPs

Found on Slashdot on Thursday, 26 November 2009
Browse Legal-Issues

The Australian court case between the film industry and ISP iiNet drew to a close yesterday after the film studios issued an ultimatum: Take copyright responsibilities seriously or leave the industry.

'They provide a facility that is able to be used for copyright infringement purposes. If they don't like having to deal with copyright notices then they should get out of the business.'

I guess with the same argumentation, photocopiers, DVD recorders, harddrives and computers should be illegal too. If someone from the media industry is reading this: that was sarcasm.

Copyright Time Bomb Set to Disrupt Music, Publishing Industries

Found on Wired on Friday, 13 November 2009
Browse Legal-Issues

If an artist or author sold a copyright before 1978 (Section 304), they or their heirs can take it back 56 years later. If the artist or author sold the copyright during or after 1978 (Section 203), they can terminate that grant after 35 years.

Sony Music filed a new copyright for the remastered version of Ben Folds Five's Whatever and Ever Amen album, and when Omega Record Group remastered a 1991 Christmas recording, the basis of its new copyright claim was "New Matter: sound recording remixed and remastered to fully utilize the sonic potential of the compact disc medium."

This might sound familiar, because BlueBeat.com employed similar logic in creating new copyrights to Beatles songs - right before it was sued by EMI and a judge barred them from continuing to sell the songs.

Hopefully a lot of musicians will terminate their contracts with the music industry and work directly with their fans. After all, the industry has proven that there is no interest in representing the artists, but only in trying to squeeze more and more money out of everybody.

Switzerland takes Google to court

Found on BBC News on Thursday, 12 November 2009
Browse Legal-Issues

Google said it was disappointed by the move. The firm says it is convinced that Swiss View is legal in Switzerland and will "vigorously contest" the case.

Mr Thuer is especially concerned about people shown in sensitive locations such as hospitals, prisons or schools.

He also said that the height of the camera was problematic because it allowed a view over fences, hedges and walls, meaning that more could be seen from Street View than by a normal passer-by.

Of course Google thinks it's legal. Luckily, this means nothing. It's something about privacy and private property; something Google never understood.