Busta Rhymes Backs Megaupload, Says Record Labels Are The Real Criminals

Found on Techdirt on Saturday, 21 January 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

Plenty of big name artists -- especially in the hip hop world -- use the paid accounts to make themselves money. This is how they release tracks. You sign up for a paid account from services like Megaupload, which pay you if you get a ton of downloads.

If they do deals with labels, they know they'll never see a dime. Putting music on Megaupload is a way to get paid. Working with a gatekeeper is not.

That's why the major labels are so freaked out by cyberlockers. It's not because there's so much infringement on there, but because it's a system whereby artists can get paid and can better distribute their own works to fans... without signing an indentured servitude contract with a label, which never pays any royalties.

It seems clear that the real fear on the part of the RIAA and the major labels is not so much about that. It's the recognition that such a distribution and payment system undermines much of their reason for existing, and takes away their ability to control artists.

That about sums it up. The entertainment industry is trying to somehow stay important when it is not really needed anymore.

Iranian court upholds Web programmer's death sentence

Found on CNet News on Friday, 20 January 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

The death sentence of Malekpour, who was convicted of "insulting and desecrating Islam" for developing software used by porn sites, was confirmed this week by Iran's Supreme Court. The software that Malekpour developed enables photos to be uploaded online and, according to Amnesty International, was used by a porn site without his knowledge.

Malekpour rescinded his confessions in a letter he sent from prison that said that he was physically and psychologically tortured and was promised an immediate release if he gave a false confession.

Malekpour wrote in his March 2010 letter. "I was forced to add that when somebody visited my website, the software would be, without his/her knowledge, installed on their computer and would take control of their webcam, even when their webcam is turned off."

Religion of peace, sure. You get a death sentence for a bit of nudity while at the same time guards rape virgins because in Iran, it is illegal to execute a woman if she is a virgin.

Murdoch slams White House over SOPA in Twitter row

Found on The Register on Sunday, 15 January 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

“So Obama has thrown in his lot with Silicon Valley paymasters who threaten all software creators with piracy, plain thievery,” he posted on his recently-started Twitter account. “Piracy leader is Google who streams movies free, sells advts around them. No wonder pouring millions into lobbying.”

The statement said that the White House couldn’t support the current legislation as it would interfere with the use of the DNS architecture which underlies most current internet use.

Rupert should better shut up. His way to run a media empire might have been fine in the past, but for today, he is just too old for it and fails to grasp the new concepts needed to be successful. He's just crying like a spoiled little kid because politics shift away from him as one of the paymasters; he doesn't get what he wants and now he's stomping his foot down and crying wolf.

UK student faces extradition to US after piracy case ruling

Found on The Register on Friday, 13 January 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

A 23-year-old student is facing extradition to the US, and possibly five years in a federal prison, after the British courts ruled he should face charges of copyright infringement for linking to websites hosting pirated content.

O’Dwyer gave evidence that TVShack “worked exactly like the Google search engine… (it)…. directed users through the use of searches to websites… at no point was there any infringing material, such as movies or programmes on my server. It just directed users to other websites by providing the link”.

O’Dwyer is being extradited under controversial laws agreed by Tony Blair in the wake of the September 11 attacks – then billed as essential to the war on terrorism - which are currently being used to try and extradite Gary McKinnon on hacking charges.

That's simply abuse of the law. O’Dwyer did nothing that is basically illegal. He linked to content, something that every website does, something that's the basic idea behind the Internet. If the targets of those links fail to secure their content, then it's their problem. There are enough methods available to stop direct linking to content, but they chose simply not to do it. Then O’Dwyer build a website which users liked and for that he should now go to jail. Google too points to tons of copyrighted material; in fact most probably just use Google to find what they want.

Grooveshark now feels lawsuit wrath of all major music labels

Found on CNet News on Friday, 06 January 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

A breach-of-contract lawsuit filed yesterday against Grooveshark means that all the major recording labels are suing the popular music streaming service.

The free-music service has become a dartboard of late for the recording industry's lawsuits. Sony Music Entertainment and Warner Music Group filed a lawsuit last month accusing the company of copyright infringement.

I wish they would really reform copyright law. Three or four years of copyright protection is enough. After that, music should be free to use. In your everyday job, you don't get paid for some work you did 30 years ago. You get paid for what you do today.

US Threatened To Blacklist Spain For Not Implementing Site Blocking Law

Found on TorrentFreak on Thursday, 05 January 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

In a leaked letter sent to Spain’s outgoing President, the US ambassador to the country warned that as punishment for not passing a SOPA-style file-sharing site blocking law, Spain risked being put on a United States trade blacklist.

More than 100 leaked cables showed that the US had helped draft new Spanish copyright legislation and had heavily influenced the decisions of both the government and opposition.

Solomont’s threat was that should Spain not pass the Sinde Law (described by some as the Spanish SOPA) then the country would be degraded further and placed on the Priority Watch List. This serious step would mean that Spain was in breach of trade agreements and could be subjected to a range of “retaliatory actions”.

Sweet secret diplomatics. It's always nice to see such extortions blow up right into their faces, showing the real truth behind those smiling faces. Exactly this is why whistleblowers and services like Wikeleaks are needed. Or better: required. Nations always need to be afraid that their shady practices get uncovered, otherwise there would never be an end to them.

Mystery surrounds Universal's takedown of Megaupload YouTube video

Found on CNet News on Saturday, 17 December 2011
Browse Legal-Issues

The video was back up after UMG failed to assert valid ownership rights, but the company is now saying it never claimed copyright ownership. Even though UMG used YouTube's automated tools for copyright owners to request takedowns under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, UMG says in a new court document that it wasn't claiming a DMCA violation.

"UMG is now claiming that it has a private, automated censorship right--supported by a secret process that can take down any YouTube video with immunity from the DMCA--and there is nothing that this Court could do about it," he wrote in a court filing today.

So UMG uses a DMCA tool from Youtube to remove a video it has no rights to, but points out it's not because of a DMCA violation while refusing to explain the reason for the takedown. I'm not a lawyer, but I guess a judge won't like this explanation.

Did French President Sarkozy download pirated movies, music?

Found on CNet News on Thursday, 15 December 2011
Browse Legal-Issues

An associate of the Nikopik Web site found IP addresses allocated to the Elysee Palace, Sarkozy's residence, on YouHaveDownloaded.com, a Russian-based site that tracks public downloads from BitTorrent.

The TorrentFreak blog used YouHaveDownloaded.com earlier this week to discover that IP addresses within Sony Pictures, NBC Universal, and Fox were listed as having downloaded pirated material from BitTorrent.

Well, well, well, what do we have here?

Senator Wyden wants answers from DHS over domain name seizures

Found on Ars Technica on Sunday, 11 December 2011
Browse Legal-Issues

"I expect the administration will be receiving a series of FOIA [Freedom of Information Act] requests from our office and that the senator will have very pointed questions with regard to how the administration chooses to target the sites that it does," said Jennifer Hoelzer, a Wyden spokeswoman.

Wyden’s interest comes a day after federal authorities returned the domain name dajaz1.com, which was back online greeting visitors Friday with a powerful message about proposed web-censorship legislation that expands the government—and copyright holders—power to shutter and cripple sites suspected of copyright infringement.

The only publicly available court record regarding the seizure was the initial filing of a court order a year ago. Everything else was sealed—invisible to Splash, his lawyer, the public and the press.

My question is why Wyden is interested now. This has been going on for a year, and now that the domain has been returned to its owner, the senator decides to join the game. While it isn't bad that he's showing interest, he should have done so earlier.

Apple Made A Deal With The Devil (No, Worse: A Patent Troll)

Found on Techcrunch on Saturday, 10 December 2011
Browse Legal-Issues

Digitude was founded in 2010 and raised $50 million from Altitude Capital Partners, with aims to “acquire, aggregate, and license key technology areas within the consumer electronics and related technology fields in a patent consortium” — in other words, it buys up patents and then sues other companies until they settle and agree to pay licensing fees.

Apple appears to have transferred its patents to the patent troll Digitude, though it first routed them through a shell company that shares the same office as Digitude’s lead investor and Chairman. Further evidence of the relationship between Apple and Digitude can be found on the ITC’s own website, where a list of files relevant to the lawsuit can be found.

If Apple were deliberately aiding Digitude, Samuels says “it would be horrifying — the patent troll problem is completely out of control. Apple has every legal right to sue over its patents, but it should be the one to do it”.

Sweet software patents. The breeding ground for an army of trolls and fake companies who make millions by doing nothing but sueing others over patents they simply bought.