Fabrice Muamba: Racist Twitter user jailed for 56 days

Found on BBC News on Wednesday, 28 March 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

Sentencing Stacey at Swansea Magistrates' Court, District Judge John Charles told him: "In my view, there is no alternative to an immediate prison sentence.

"It was not the football world who was praying for [Muamba].... everybody was praying for his life."

Writing on Twitter, Lord Sugar - former Spurs chairman - saying "Be warned idiots!," while Gary Lineker posted "Let it be a warning to all you immature souls. #thinkbeforeyoutweet".

Lord Sugar seems very mature and above all this indeed with his respone. Putting the racial part aside, Muamba is a person like everybody else, and every single day, thousands of people around the world collapse. How can a judge assume every is praying for him, even those who never heard about him before all this? If all people are equal, everybody would have to spend the whole day with praying.

FBI Still Struggling With Supreme Court's GPS Ruling

Found on NPR on Saturday, 24 March 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

Earlier this year, the Supreme Court said police had overstepped their legal authority by planting a GPS tracker on the car of a suspected drug dealer without getting a search warrant.

But after the ruling, FBI officials tell NPR, agents still had to turn off 250 devices that they couldn't turn back on.

"We have a number of people in the United States whom we could not indict, there is not probable cause to indict them or to arrest them who present a threat of terrorism. ... [They] may be up on the Internet, may have purchased a gun, but have taken no particular steps to take a terrorist act."

They use the Internet, own a gun and have done nothing illegal. Wow. That's the majority in the US.

Court Orders RapidShare to Filter User Uploads

Found on TorrentFreak on Monday, 19 March 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

A Higher Regional Court in Germany has ruled that file-hosting service RapidShare must proactively filter thousands of files uploaded by its users.

The Higher Regional Court in Hamburg reportedly ruled that RapidShare has to monitor user uploads to ensure that none of these titles are put onto their servers, which implies a mandatory filter and monitoring of all user uploads.

While a written copy of the verdict has not yet been made public, the book industry celebrated the outcome as a landmark victory.

I wonder how they will monitor encrypted files like "hKD2cX2.dat".

Belgian rightsholders group wants to charge libraries for reading books to kids

Found on The Next Web on Saturday, 17 March 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

People with a healthy interest in fundamental freedoms and basic human rights have probably heard about SABAM, the Belgian collecting society for music royalties, which has become one of the global poster children for how outrageously out of touch with reality certain rightsholders groups appear to be.

This morning, word got out in Belgian media that SABAM is spending time and resources to contact local libraries across the nation, warning them that they will start charging fees because the libraries engage volunteers to read books to kids.

SABAM got in touch with the library to let them know that it thinks this is unacceptable, however, and that they should start coughing up cash for the audacity to read stories from copyrighted books out loud. The library rep calculates that it could cost them roughly 250 euros (which is about $328) per year to pay SABAM for the right to – again – READ BOOKS TO KIDS.

Copyrights really need a reform. Soon you will have to pay fees because your neighbour can hear you whistle in the shower.

12-year-old sues school district over Facebook profile search

Found on CNet News on Sunday, 11 March 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

The girl--referred to in the court papers as R.S.--apparently felt that her hall monitor was mean to her and therefore described her as "mean" on her Facebook profile. She claims that no school equipment or property were used to make her postings.

The ACLU declared in a statement: "Students do not shed their First Amendment rights at the school house gate. The Supreme Court ruled on that in the 1970s, yet schools like Minnewaska seem to have no regard for the standard."

The school has no right to spy around in a students online life. There is no demand for an orwellian society; except by those who love to spy and trample privacy.

Hotfile As Bad As Megaupload, MPAA Tells Court

Found on TorrentFreak on Thursday, 08 March 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

“Hotfile’s business model is indistinguishable from that of the website Megaupload, which recently was indicted criminally for engaging in the very same conduct as Hotfile. Defendants even admit that they formed Hotfile ‘to compete with’ Megaupload.”

“Hotfile is responsible for billions of infringing downloads of copyrighted works, including plaintiffs’ valuable motion picture and television properties. As with other adjudicated pirate services that came before it, from Napster and Grokster to Isohunt and Limewire, Hotfile exists to profit from copyright infringement,” they write.

Megaupload's case isn't even in court, yet the MPAA already claims victory and wants more sites to be shut down. Sites which, like Megaupload, supposedly caused billions of losses, sums which make you wonder if people are spending money on anything else but music and movies. Plus, in a classical "pot and kettle" moment, let's not forget that Hollywood was founded to infringe patents and copyrights. Just ask the MPPC.

Kim DotCom: Why didn't MPAA sue me?

Found on CNet News on Thursday, 01 March 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

Internet service providers are protected from liability for copyright violations committed by users if they obey the DMCA's requirements. DotCom said MegaUpload adhered closely to the DMCA's requirements.

He said that while individual copyright owners had been critical of the service, not one major film studio or record company had ever filed suit against MegaUpload or even sent him a cease and desist letter.

MegaUpload was founded in 2005. Wouldn't at least one of the big studios or record companies have taken him to court during that time? The government has said the criminal investigation lasted two years. That leaves the prior five years that the copyright owners, according to DotCom, did nothing to get in his way.

Interesting questions. Let's wait for the answers from the entertainment industry.

Megaupload Founder Defeats US Govt Attempts To Put Him Back In Prison

Found on TorrentFreak on Wednesday, 29 February 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

Upset at the decision to grant Dotcom freedom, the US Government, argued yesterday in an appeal hearing that he should be put back in jail. Today they failed in that attempt and Dotcom remains a free man – at least for now.

Crown prosecutor Anne Toohey told the court yesterday that since Dotcom’s release last week two further banks accounts had been discovered – one in the Philippines and another in the British Virgin Islands containing $2000.

She said that this, along with allegations that Dotcom might have access to forged travel documents, was enough to have the 38-year-old put back in prison.

Access to a $2000 bank account and an unproven assumption that he might have access to forged passports. If that's all they have to justify his jail time, then they could lock up pretty much everybody.

France's bold drink driving legislation - every car to carry a breathalyzer

Found on Gizmag on Monday, 27 February 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

From July of this year, it will become law in France to have a working breathalyzer in every car on the road, with enforcement beginning November 1.

The breathalyzer laws in France will be strictly enforced, with lots of spot checks and failure to provide a working breathalyzer when requested by a traffic policeman will attract a fine of EUR11.00 (US$14).

So buy a $2 breathalyzer and store it in your car. When police checks you, pull it out to show them. When they ask why there is no used breathalyzer (since you had to use one before you started to drive) you can always tell them that you already threw it away; after all, why keep trash in your car?

SABAM Charged With Copyright Fraud, Embezzlement, Money Laundering

Found on TorrentFreak on Tuesday, 21 February 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

Belgian music rights group SABAM has a serious headache looming. Following a complaint filed by an artist back in 2004, a judge began investigating the group’s finances. His findings mean that SABAM will now face court accused of falsifying accounts to cover up bribe payments, abuse of trust, copyright fraud and embezzlement.

Former SABAM President Jacques Leduc is one of the accused but former financial directors Marcel Raiglot and Jean Huysmans and current finance director Luc Van Oycke are being held accountable for corruption and forgery.

"For the artists".