One day after DC police's reasonable camera policy, phone still taken

Found on Ars Technica on Thursday, 26 July 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

On July 20, just 24 hours after a new camera policy was enacted by the Metropolitan Police Department of Washington, DC—you guessed it—the cops still took a guy’s phone. The new policy forbids the confiscation of cameras and cameraphones, and disallows police from ordering citizens to stop filming or taking photos of police action.

"So I go and grab my phone and start trying to record it," Staley told Fox 5 News in the District. "And once I do that, another vice cop reaches over my back and grabs my phone and tells me he's not giving my phone back."

“A member [of the police department] shall not, implicitly or explicitly, coerce consent to take possession of any recording device or any information thereon,” the new order states.

Officers have to respect the laws too; they are not above it. Let's see how the MPD handles this.

Judge frees nude TSA protester, citing free speech rights

Found on The Register on Friday, 20 July 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

The techie who stripped naked to protest invasive airport security, saying he was sick and tired of being harassed by Transportation Security Administration screeners, has been cleared of all charges.

As his supporters cheered the verdict, one friend stuck a Post-it note on Brennan's chest. On it was written "Sir Godiva", thus linking the now-exonerated and fully clothed protester with another defender of justice who stood up and stripped down for good cause.

I thought the TSA wants to see everything; but when someone shows everything, they get angry.

Rights Group Fined For Not Paying Artist For Anti-Piracy Ad

Found on TorrentFreak on Tuesday, 17 July 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

When Rietveldt bought a Harry Potter DVD in 2007, he discovered his music being used in the anti-piracy ad without his permission. In fact, it had been used on dozens of DVDs both in the Netherlands and overseas.

In June, Stemra paid Rietveld another 31,000 euros but this week the Amsterdam District Court ruled that Stemra had indeed been negligent in their handling of the case. They were fined 20,000 euros, ordered to pay Rietveldt’s legal costs, and told to continue efforts to pay all money due to the composer while keeping him fully informed of developments.

Oh the sweet irony.

Kim DotCom extradition hearing postponed until 2013

Found on CNet News on Tuesday, 10 July 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

The extradition hearing for MegaUpload founder Kim DotCom has been postponed to next year over questions about the legality of evidence seized with search warrants later declared invalid.

The legality of the evidence seized was called into question last month when a New Zealand judge ruled that the warrants did not adequately describe the offenses alleged and as such were invalid. She also ruled that it was unlawful for the data confiscated in the raid to have been copied by the FBI and sent offshore.

This delay obviously only benefits Hollywood, unless Megaupload is allowed to go back online again until everything is sorted out, because for now, all the "evidence" turned out to be pretty flimsy. Not to mention the illegal raid. So it would be only fair to make Megaupload accessible again; after all, right now it still is a perfectly legal service. This effectively ruins Megaupload, like Hollywood planned it, and the USA will simply refuse to pay any damages.

French police search Nicolas Sarkozy home and office

Found on BBC News on Tuesday, 03 July 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

The investigation is related to allegations that Mr Sarkozy's 2007 presidential election campaign received illegal donations from France's richest woman, Liliane Bettencourt.

An investigating magistrate is looking into claims that staff acting for the L'Oreal heiress Liliane Bettencourt, gave 150,000 euros in cash to Mr Sarkozy's aides during his 2007 bid to become president.

In addition, there are other witnesses who allege that during the 2007 campaign, Mr Sarkozy made several private visits to Ms Bettencourt's home.

Nice to see that a former president, who fought so hard to stop people from downloading a few songs and to get them cut off from the Internet as a result, seems to have no problem to accept illegal donations for his own benefit.

Dotcom search warrants ruled illegal

Found on Sydney Morning Herald on Thursday, 28 June 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

A New Zealand High Court judge has ruled that police search warrants used to seize property from Megaupload's founder Kim Dotcom were illegal.

Kim Dotcom was arrested in January when the FBI shut down his fire-sharing website aming claims it had cost copyright holders more than $US500 million in lost revenue from pirated films and other content.

She said that police without a valid warrant were trespassing and exceeded what they were lawfully authorised to do.

Still, the MPAA/RIAA has achieved what it wanted: with the help of the FBI, it shut down his entire business. Not to mention that the FBI also stole his private data by making copies of his harddrives and secretly sneaking them out and to the US. It's pretty amazing what the entertainment industry can start while at the same time patent trolls cost $29 billion, and not just $500 million (a number which is only based on their assumptions of course and with no facts behind it). It would be fun to have a judge decide that the US has to pay compensation; which they of course would refuse to do.

'Patent trolls' cost other US bodies $29bn last year, says study

Found on BBC News on Wednesday, 27 June 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

The direct cost of actions taken by so-called "patent trolls" totalled $29bn in the US in 2011, according to a study by Boston University.

They include businesses that buy patents with the sole aim of licensing them out, individual inventors, universities and companies that assert patent rights unrelated to the products they make.

"Even so, the direct costs are large relative to total spending on [research and development], which totalled $247bn in 2009, implying that NPE patent assertations effectively impose a significant tax on investment in innovation."

Trolls and lawyers, what an ugly combination. It's time to come up with a new patent system and abolish the current one. Or for a start, patents should be tied to a single person, without the option to sell them.

Typosquatter Used Misspelled Domains to Intercept Email, Claims $1 Million Lawsuit

Found on Wired on Monday, 25 June 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

A man accused of typosquatting is being sued for $1 million by a law firm that alleges he set up a domain that mimics the law firm’s domain name.

The firm also asserts that clients or prospective clients “may attempt to contact our attorneys or staff using the Group’s e-mail address, and misspell the e-mail address as ‘@GiocondoloLaw.com’, which would then be intercepted by the unauthorized Registrant.”

Although this is pretty much the mistake of whoever sent the email to the wrong recipient, Kenzie will probably end up in some really hot water, especially since he tried before to sell a domain for $295 by threatening to reveal that the domain was successfully used for typosquatting.

Police: 'Threat matrix' dictated SWAT team response at Powell Avenue home

Found on Courier Press on Saturday, 23 June 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

Dressed in full protective gear, police broke the storm door of the home at 616 East Powell Ave. — the Milans’ front door was already open on the hot summer day. They also broke a front window. They tossed a flashbang stun grenade into the living room that made a deafening blast. A short distance away, a local television crew’s cameras were rolling. The police had invited the station to videotape the forced entry of the residence.

Ira Milan said the perpetrator of the threats likely used Stephanie’s Internet service connection from an outside location, which led police to the East Powell Avenue address.

“This is a little more difficult that a traditional crime scene, because we’re dealing with the Internet. They definitely weren’t expecting (a SWAT team at the door). The reason we did that is the threats were specific enough, and the potential for danger was there.

“This is a big deal to us,” Cullum said. “This may be just somebody who was online just talking stupid. What I would suggest to anybody who visits websites like that is that their comments can be taken literally.”

Overreaction much? Just because some troll posts on some forum, there's no need to bring in a whole SWAT team; there's always the traditional police work without using excessive force and violence against innocent citizens. Of course, traditional police work don't scare citizens who might prefer to shut up instead to talk about other issues, fearing a visit from a SWAT team. Maybe one day he will learn "dealing with the Internet", that dangerous and highly aggressive beast which Cullum is so afraid of that he needs military-grade backup just to ask the owner of the house some questions.

Google Threatens To Sue Huge YouTube MP3 Conversion Site

Found on TorrentFreak on Wednesday, 20 June 2012
Browse Legal-Issues

According to a letter seen by TorrentFreak, Google are threatening action against one of the web’s largest YouTube conversion sites. The site, which according to Google’s own stats is pulling in 1.3 million visitors every day, extracts MP3 audio from YouTube videos and makes it available for users to download.

Cohen underlines the fact that to “separate, isolate, or modify the audio or video components of any YouTube audiovisual content made available through the YouTube API” is forbidden, as is externally storing copies of YouTube content.

So Youtube wants to stop users from saving the videos? Well, Google better shuts Youtube down then, because this is the only way to enfore this rule. For every major browser there are numerous plugins which add a download option to every video.