Protecting our brand from a global spyware provider

Found on The Mozilla Blog on Wednesday, 01 May 2013
Browse Legal-Issues

A recent report by Citizen Lab uncovered that commercial spyware produced by Gamma International is designed to trick people into thinking it’s Mozilla Firefox. We’ve sent Gamma a cease and desist letter today demanding that these illegal practices stop immediately.

Gamma’s software is entirely separate, and only uses our brand and trademarks to lie and mislead as one of its methods for avoiding detection and deletion.

Good luck Mozilla. Although I'm not too happy with the path Mozilla picked for Firefox, I still hope they will win against Gamma. Now if Gamma would have only downloaded a single mp3...

Man allegedly put GPS on woman's car before burglary

Found on CNet News on Sunday, 28 April 2013
Browse Legal-Issues

The owner of one of the homes believes that Glaze found a simple way of discovering if she and her son were home. He allegedly placed a GPS device on their cars.

GPS devices are easy to buy and use these days. It's impossible to always know whether one is being tracked or not.

If the FBI can hide a GPS on your car to track you, so can criminals. It's just a logical development.

Undercover cops' devious new method to stop iPhone theft

Found on CNet News on Saturday, 27 April 2013
Browse Legal-Issues

Police in San Francisco decide on a new tactic to stop iPhone theft. Undercover officers are walking down streets offering to sell iPhones they claim are stolen. The idea is to kill the market for stolen phones.

It wouldn't be hard to imagine that not everyone admires this police tactic. It seems as if the undercover officers are luring people to commit a crime.

That plan worked so perfectly before that there are no drug problems anymore.

Movie Studios Want Google to Take Down Their Own Takedown Request

Found on TorrentFreak on Saturday, 06 April 2013
Browse Legal-Issues

In a comical display of meta-censorship several copyright holders including 20th Century Fox and NBC Universal have sent Google takedown requests asking the search engine to take down links to takedown request they themselves sent. Google refused to comply with the movie studios requests and the “infringing” DMCA notices remain online. Meanwhile, the number of takedown notices received by Google is nearing 20 million per month.

No longer is Google merely asked to remove direct links to copyrighted material as the DMCA prescribes, but also links to links to links to copyrighted material.

So under the DMCA that complains about the previous DMCA links, this first one should be invalidated. After all that's what copyright owners want: file a DMCA to remove all traces. Taking this to the next logical step, this could mean that the previously removed links can appear online again because the DMCA that removed them just was invalidated by a DMCA.

Why Rackspace Is Suing The Most Notorious Patent Troll In America

Found on Rackspace on Friday, 05 April 2013
Browse Legal-Issues

Parallel Iron is the latest in a string of shell companies created to do nothing more than assert patent-infringement claims as part of a typical patent troll scheme of pressuring companies to pay up or else face crippling litigation costs.

IP Nav told us that they could not divulge the details of their infringement claims – not even the patent numbers or the patent owner – unless we entered into a “forbearance agreement” – basically, an agreement that we would not sue them.

Patent trolls brazenly use questionable tactics to force settlements from legitimate businesses that are merely using computers and software as they are intended.

With a single change of the law hundreds of troll companies would go out of business. That's what would help innovation more than any patent ever could.

ReDigi Loses: You Can't Resell Your MP3s (Unless You Sell Your Whole Hard Drive)

Found on Techdirt on Monday, 01 April 2013
Browse Legal-Issues

The ruling is still fairly distressing in just how badly it distorts other parts of the law, which may harm other, even more reasonable uses. Hopefully, ReDigi will appeal and fight back against the more extreme interpretation from the district court here.

Effectively, the court wipes out first sale for digital goods, arguing that because (as above) each transfer is not really a "transfer" but a "copy," first sale doesn't apply. That is, first sale only applies to the initial "copy" "made under this title." But, the court argues, because the sale involves making a new copy, it's not covered by first sale.

There's a simple fix: just download all your legally paid music to CD first. From this one you can make copies for your personal use and if you don't want it anymore, just sell the CD. EMI could do nothing against that because it would be totally legal according to this ruling.

Developer Freedom At Stake As Oracle Clings To Java API Copyrights In Google Fight

Found on Techcrunch on Sunday, 31 March 2013
Browse Legal-Issues

You could hear a collective sigh of relief from the software developer world when Judge William Alsup issued his ruling in the Oracle-Google lawsuit. Oracle lost on pretty much every point.

Oracle lost in their attempt to protect their position using patents. They lost in their attempt to claim Google copied anything but a few lines of code. If they succeed in claiming you need their permission to use the Java APIs that they pushed as a community standard, software developers and innovation will be the losers.

Oracle never really learns. If they manage to succceed in the next lawsuit, Java will be dropped like a hot cup of coffee. Oracle made that mistake already when it tried to force OpenOffice to behave like they wanted it; now we have LibreOffice and the percentage of OpenOffice drops constantly.

GoPro can fall from planes with no parachute, can’t get copyright law

Found on ArsTechnica on Thursday, 21 March 2013
Browse Legal-Issues

A GoPro "brand manager" has sent a DMCA takedown notice to DigitalRev, a photography shopping and discussion site. The review, titled "GOPRO Hero 3 vs SONY HDR-AS15—Which Action Camera should you get?" isn't up anymore. Instead, it has been replaced with a letter from GoPro.

DigitalRev has a blog post up about the takedown, suggesting that most DMCA takedowns are "abusive" in nature. "We hope GoPro is not suggesting, with this DMCA notice, that camera reviews should be done only when they are authorized by the manufacturers," writes DigitalRev.

It would make much more sense if bogus DMCA takedown notices would cause problems for those who sent them.

Speed cameras are a scam, Ohio judge rules

Found on CNet News on Sunday, 10 March 2013
Browse Legal-Issues

Some localities have come to admit that they don't reduce accidents. Arizona took the decision to remove its highway speed cameras altogether.

Locals decided this resembled backstreet robbery and so went to court, also offering the legal defense that the cameras were installed without displaying the appropriate public notices to warn people this was coming.

The attorney for the plaintiffs, Mike Allen, however, told the Columbus Dispatch: "This is the first time that a judge has said 'enough is enough'. I think this nationally is a turning point."

I doubt there are many drivers who will disagree with the judge.

Pirate Bay quits Sweden to relieve pressure on bandwidth provider

Found on IT World on Tuesday, 26 February 2013
Browse Legal-Issues

The Pirate Bay has opened two new gateways to its internal network in order to shield its current Internet provider, the Swedish Pirate Party, which had been threatened with legal action if it did not stop providing Internet access to the torrent search site by Tuesday.

The Swedish Pirate Party has had a hectic time since the legal threats arrived, said the party's leader Anna Troberg in a news release on Tuesday. Individuals that would be targeted by the Right's Alliance lawsuit discussed possible consequences of litigation with their families because they could have had a big impact on their lives, she said, adding that it has been "a tough emotional process" for everyone involved.

The industry could just quit this cat and mouse game; they cannot win.